Potters Cay Fish Fry

Potter’s Cay Fish Fry is a popular seafood and cultural attraction in Nassau. Notably popular with Bahamians, it is considered the Locals Fish Fry when compared to the more touristy nature of Arawak Cay Fish Fry.

While the capital of the Bahamas is full of fresh and delicious food, Potters Cay Nassau might take home the prize. From conch fritters and Bahamian cracked lobster to fried fish and more, some of the top Nassau Fish Fry restaurants are on this tiny island beneath the Paradise Island bridge.

Good to Know

Location: Potters Cay, under the road bridge from Paradise Island

How Long to Spend: 1-2 hours

TripAdvisor Rating: 4 stars.

Nearby Attractions: Paradise Island, Atlantis Resort, Rum Cake Factory, Fort Montagu

Entry Fees: No entry fees

Potters Cay Fish Fry: Home to the Nassau Fish Fry Restaurants

The Potters Cay Nassau bahamas fish fry is located on the waters edge of Nassau Harbour - with stunning views across to Paradise Island and the Atlantis Resort.

You’ll find some shops and stalls mixed into the strip of restaurants.

Potters Cay Nassau: How to Visit

Potters Cay Nassau is located right near a plethora of Downtown attractions, making it easy to visit while on your Bahamas vacation.

For travelers entering through the cruise port, a short walk east down Bay Street will have you at Fish Fry Nassau Bahamas in around 25 to 30 minutes. If you don’t feel like making that journey or the sun feels oppressive, a taxi can get you to the island in a jiffy.

Tourists on other parts of New Providence or Paradise Island should also take taxis or look into taking a bus. Depending on where you’re staying, the local jitneys can be convenient ways to traverse the island. Just make sure you know the route beforehand and have small bills, as most drivers won’t give you change.

Potters Cay Nassau is a Fish Fry located under the bridge from Paradise Island. Many fish fry shacks offer local Bahamas cuisine.

Potters Cay Nassau is under the bridge to Paradise Island.

Fish Fry Nassau Bahamas: Where Is It?

While Arawak Cay may be the more famous Fish Fry Nassau Bahamas location, Potters Cay Nassau is just as easy to visit. You’ll also find even fewer tourists there, with most of the patrons making their way to the restaurants and shops being locals.

The strip of restaurants is under the Paradise Island bridge. If you’re on New Providence, the entrance to the area is before the bridge, so if you’re walking and make it to the bridge itself, you’ve gone too far.

What to See at Potters Cay

Potters Cay Nassau may be humble, but it offers some of the top Nassau Fish Fry restaurants. Because of that, it’s a destination you’ll want to put on your Bahamas itinerary.

The Restaurants and Food

Of course, the highlight of any Fish Fry Nassau Bahamas location is the restaurants and food. At Potters Cay Nassau, you can look forward to diving into a variety of authentic Bahamian dishes.

McKenzie's Fish Fry at Potters Cay Nassau offers Bahamian Cooking style menus including the very popular Conch Fritters.

Fresh seafood and a cold beer are just a short journey away from Downtown.

Conch is the national food of the Bahamas and is something you need to try while visiting the archipelago. Like squid, which it resembles, you can have it in literally dozens of different ways, from raw to fried and as salads. Potters Cay is a great place to try it.

Bahamian cracked lobster is another famous dish, and another great option to try while in the area. The same goes for any fried fish, as you can bet that it’ll be freshly caught from the nearby waters that same day.

Bahamas Cracked Lobster (Craw Fish) is a local Bahamian way of cooking Lobster and fish dishes at the Potters Cay Nassau FIsh Fry.

Bahamian cracked lobster is another Fish Fry Nassau specialty.

The Markets

Besides eating, the strip is also home to different shops and markets. From picking up fresh fruit to buying your own freshly caught conch, there are several interesting venues worth exploring.

A word of advice: If you do plan on actually buying something from the market, make sure to barter a bit, as the initial price offered will probably be high.

Potters Cay Fish Fry Travel Tips

Don’t be turned off by the appearance: Potters Cay Nassau isn’t a strip of five-star restaurants – it’s a collection of shacks and stalls under a bridge. However, while it might be rustic, the food rivals that of any upscale Nassau restaurant. Don’t let the appearance of the strip turn you off.
Try the conch salad: While you can have conch served in dozens of different ways, conch salad is extra special. When you eat it at Potters Cay Nassau, you’ll see fishermen collect the conchs from the water and prepare the dish right in front of you. It doesn’t get any fresher than that!
Enjoy the views: You might not think that restaurants under a bridge would offer good views, but many of them do. Stretched out over the water, you can look down into the crystal-clear blue and see fish, rays, nurse sharks, and other animals. As you eat, you’ll also see boats floating around the harbor, and eventually, the sun setting in the distance. Savor it all.
Timing: Plan to visit in the late afternoon or evening. The atmosphere becomes livelier as the day progresses, with more stalls open and the entertainment picking up.
Cash is King: Bring cash in Bahamian dollars. While some vendors may accept credit cards, having cash on hand will ensure you’re prepared to make purchases.
Local Beverages: Pair your meal with local drinks like Bahamian fruit punches or the iconic “Sky Juice,” a coconut-based cocktail.
Sunset Views: If you time it right, you might get to enjoy a beautiful sunset over the ocean as you dine.

Inside McKenzie's Potters Cay Nassau Fish Fry restaurant, a popular Bahamian Cuisine restaurant in Nassau Bahamas.

The restaurants at Potters Cay Nassau serve some of the best food on the island.

Fish Fry Paradise Island: A Taste of the Bahamas

Potters Cay Nassau serves up some of the freshest and most delicious food on the island. Whether you’re a seafood fanatic or just someone looking to go where the locals go, Fish Fry Paradise Island might be the destination you need.

Nassau is full of hidden gems like Potters Cay. If you’re on the hunt for more destinations and insider travel tips, make sure to check out our other articles as well as our interactive travel map of Nassau & Paradise Island.